TY - BOOK
T1 - Fashion Worth Circulating
AU - Dalgaard Nielsen, Mette
N1 - The three articles of the dissertation are either published or under review in academic journals. They are therefore blurred in the uploaded edition and should be accessed and referenced via the journals in the future. Details regarding titles, journals, and contents are provided in the dissertation.
PY - 2025
Y1 - 2025
N2 - This article-based PhD dissertation, "Fashion Worth Circulating", concerns the resale of clothing, challenging the dominant linear fashion industry by looking for transitional pathways in the rapidly growing resale economy that is grounded in promises of revitalising already existing garments. The dissertation is linked to the mission-driven research and innovation partnership TRACE (a TRAnsition towards Circular Economy) which, through a multitude of thematically joint projects, aims to accelerate the transition to a circular economy for plastics and textiles in Denmark.
Within the TRACE framework, the dissertation takes its point of departure in the specific key challenge that ‘clothing is underutilised’ (RM2021, 23), a challenge that is sought to be remedied by scaling up the resale market, where the rates of 30-40 and 80-90 percent of revenue streams in the Danish textile sector are to be generated by the years 2030 and 2050 respectively. These are the concrete milestones that form the basis of the partnership’s vision, and they thus delimit the dissertation’s particular stance on what the future circular fashion economy will look like.
Theoretically, the dissertation combines perspectives from actor-network theory (ANT), science-and-technology studies (STS), new materialism, and practice theory. It is contextualised in ongoing design-oriented debates concerning the Anthropocene thesis, which has recently emerged in design research. The intersection of these perspectives enables a conceptualisation of design as a planetary force. The dissertation thereby positions itself on a theoretical foundation that situates design as a world-making phenomenon through which the accumulation of diverse human activities continuously shapes and changes the planet – unfortunately often with far-reaching, unintended consequences. Situated in the slipstream of posthuman and systemic movements, the planetary notion of design entails an ethical obligation to design with rather than against the Earth and for habitability, equipping the dissertation with an epistemological grounding in relational and material logics.
Based on a qualitative dataset focusing on 1) businesses, whose resale-promoting business models are explored through semi-structured interviews and participant observations in workshops, 2) users, whose garment relationships and resale practices are explored through interview-based wardrobe studies, and 3) design objects, whose trajectories in selected resale environments are explored through a (n)ethnographic follow-the-garment method, the dissertation examines how clothing in practice is ’made’ circular by diverse (f)actors.
The PhD project’s exploration of how design objects in the shape of clothing perform in the present-day resale economy encourages a particular interpretation of circular fashion that constitutes a significant part of the practical and theoretical contribution of the research. From the perspective of the resale market, clothing is not circular until the moment it performs circularly by being resold and proven worthy of circulation. As a counterpoint to narrow, product-oriented perceptions of circular and durable design, the dissertation introduces a systemic and processual understanding where a garment’s lastingness may be supported by design without necessarily being caused by intentional design strategies or material product properties.
The dissertation argues that circularity is not static, measurable, or universal; not an ontological product property, a technical strength, or an aesthetic quality physically built into the design object; nor is it within the designer’s control. By cross-pollinating analytical findings from the three articles, circularity is proposed as a vibrant practice form and mode of becoming; an emergent potential that exists only when realised in practice; that often has multiple – surprising and entangled – causes; that it is not a being, but a becoming. For this reason, cultivating a circular textile economy with a resale-dominated fashion market involves 1) businesses, 2) users, and 3) design objects – but in principle also all other – human and nonhuman – (f)actors that influence the long-term survival of garments in real life.
Being informed by an expanded concept of design, the dissertation does not subscribe to the adequacy of simple solutions but emphasises the need of multi-track, systemic efforts that target root causes at several points of intervention. The dissertation proposes the idea that realising the TRACE partnership’s visions requires an interconnected web of longevity that unites multiple relational elements around the co-creation of resilient alternatives to the dominant industrial paradigm – not as isolated efforts, but in a cross-cutting collaboration that enables us to achieve more with less.
AB - This article-based PhD dissertation, "Fashion Worth Circulating", concerns the resale of clothing, challenging the dominant linear fashion industry by looking for transitional pathways in the rapidly growing resale economy that is grounded in promises of revitalising already existing garments. The dissertation is linked to the mission-driven research and innovation partnership TRACE (a TRAnsition towards Circular Economy) which, through a multitude of thematically joint projects, aims to accelerate the transition to a circular economy for plastics and textiles in Denmark.
Within the TRACE framework, the dissertation takes its point of departure in the specific key challenge that ‘clothing is underutilised’ (RM2021, 23), a challenge that is sought to be remedied by scaling up the resale market, where the rates of 30-40 and 80-90 percent of revenue streams in the Danish textile sector are to be generated by the years 2030 and 2050 respectively. These are the concrete milestones that form the basis of the partnership’s vision, and they thus delimit the dissertation’s particular stance on what the future circular fashion economy will look like.
Theoretically, the dissertation combines perspectives from actor-network theory (ANT), science-and-technology studies (STS), new materialism, and practice theory. It is contextualised in ongoing design-oriented debates concerning the Anthropocene thesis, which has recently emerged in design research. The intersection of these perspectives enables a conceptualisation of design as a planetary force. The dissertation thereby positions itself on a theoretical foundation that situates design as a world-making phenomenon through which the accumulation of diverse human activities continuously shapes and changes the planet – unfortunately often with far-reaching, unintended consequences. Situated in the slipstream of posthuman and systemic movements, the planetary notion of design entails an ethical obligation to design with rather than against the Earth and for habitability, equipping the dissertation with an epistemological grounding in relational and material logics.
Based on a qualitative dataset focusing on 1) businesses, whose resale-promoting business models are explored through semi-structured interviews and participant observations in workshops, 2) users, whose garment relationships and resale practices are explored through interview-based wardrobe studies, and 3) design objects, whose trajectories in selected resale environments are explored through a (n)ethnographic follow-the-garment method, the dissertation examines how clothing in practice is ’made’ circular by diverse (f)actors.
The PhD project’s exploration of how design objects in the shape of clothing perform in the present-day resale economy encourages a particular interpretation of circular fashion that constitutes a significant part of the practical and theoretical contribution of the research. From the perspective of the resale market, clothing is not circular until the moment it performs circularly by being resold and proven worthy of circulation. As a counterpoint to narrow, product-oriented perceptions of circular and durable design, the dissertation introduces a systemic and processual understanding where a garment’s lastingness may be supported by design without necessarily being caused by intentional design strategies or material product properties.
The dissertation argues that circularity is not static, measurable, or universal; not an ontological product property, a technical strength, or an aesthetic quality physically built into the design object; nor is it within the designer’s control. By cross-pollinating analytical findings from the three articles, circularity is proposed as a vibrant practice form and mode of becoming; an emergent potential that exists only when realised in practice; that often has multiple – surprising and entangled – causes; that it is not a being, but a becoming. For this reason, cultivating a circular textile economy with a resale-dominated fashion market involves 1) businesses, 2) users, and 3) design objects – but in principle also all other – human and nonhuman – (f)actors that influence the long-term survival of garments in real life.
Being informed by an expanded concept of design, the dissertation does not subscribe to the adequacy of simple solutions but emphasises the need of multi-track, systemic efforts that target root causes at several points of intervention. The dissertation proposes the idea that realising the TRACE partnership’s visions requires an interconnected web of longevity that unites multiple relational elements around the co-creation of resilient alternatives to the dominant industrial paradigm – not as isolated efforts, but in a cross-cutting collaboration that enables us to achieve more with less.
KW - Circular Design
KW - Circular Economy
KW - fashion and sustainability
KW - Fashion
KW - Longevity
KW - Resale
KW - circular business models
KW - New Materialism
KW - Anthropocene
KW - ANT
KW - Wardrobe Method
KW - wardrobe studies
KW - mission-based research
KW - Planetary Design
M3 - Ph.D. thesis
BT - Fashion Worth Circulating
PB - Royal Danish Academy - Architecture, Design, Conservation
CY - København
ER -